Should You Build a New Home or Buy a Fixer Upper?

Buying a home can be one of the largest investments, both financially and emotionally, that many of us will ever make. Not only do you have to consider what fits your financial situation, but you also have to consider (besides a roof over your head) what else you want out of your home.

With these considerations in mind, the debate between buying a new home and a fixer-upper becomes one with many factors to evaluate. So let’s look at some of the pros and cons of each scenario.

New Home


1. Everything’s New
In newer homes you know that all plumbing, electrical, HVAC, lighting and other systems that your house runs on are brand new and should be worry-free.

2. Fresh and Clean
“Move-in ready” is a key benefit of buying a new home. Everything – from floors to walls – is clean and fresh and requires no additional work before moving in. This can reduce the  time frame and stress level of purchasing a home.

3. Potential for Warrantees
A new home’s water heater, air conditioner, roof and other features may still be under warranty, offering peace-of-mind when it comes to replacing or repairing high-ticket items.


1. Cost
One of the downsides of moving into a newer, cleaner, up-to-date home is usually the higher price tag. You may not have a lot of repairs or replacements to make, but newer amenities can affect the overall price of the home.

2. Location
You may not find many newer homes being built in established neighborhoods, which may mean you have to look in newer subdivisions on the outskirts of the metro area.

3. Character and Charm
While a newer home will usually fit all your needs as far as living space and layout, some new homes don’t offer the architectural detail and style that give an older home its character and charm.



1. Discounted Price
One of the main benefits of buying a fixer-upper is the steep discount that often comes with such a purchase. Of course, there will be other costs involved in repairing or remodeling, but many of those costs can be offset by the discounted purchase price.

2. Architectural Style
Unless you are looking to build a high-end custom home, many newer homes do not have the same architectural detail and character as many older homes do.

3. Personal Touch
Fixing up an older home allows you to go through a similar process of building a home when it comes to making selections on flooring, paint, appliances and other finishing touches. These decisions will help personalize a well-used home into your own.


1. Time
Time constraints can be a difficult obstacle to negotiate when buying a fixer-upper. Getting the home ready while living in the space or waiting to move until all work is done can be a task that requires patience.

2. Unforeseen Issues and Costs
While walkthroughs and inspections should give you a pretty good idea of what lies ahead, there’s always the possibility that some issues or repairs will present themselves during the rehab process. Fixing these unforeseen issues can cost time and money.

3. Labor Intensive
Unless you hire someone to do all the work, which may negate the cost savings on the purchase price, be prepared to get your hands dirty. If you decide to do the work yourself, expect things to take a bit longer and possibly cost a little more than you imagine.

1 thought on “Should You Build a New Home or Buy a Fixer Upper?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s